Dirty Marketing

Many years ago I worked as a concierge at an inn in Niagara-On-The-Lake. In that position, and due to the location, part of my responsibility was to be up-to-date on information about the various wines and wineries in the area. To help with that, every Friday a different winery representative would come to the inn, give us a tasting along with a short talk, and field any questions we had.

It was an enjoyable job which sparked an interest, and to this day I still follow the world of wines, though to a much lesser degree. A bit of news that I came across a couple of months ago really annoyed me, however.

Two wine companies are in a legal battle about the naming of their wines, and it is those names that irk me. One is called “Mommyjuice,” while the other is called “Mommy’s Time Out.”

I’m not denying that this is a key demographic. In fact, wineries across the board have realized that women 25 – 40 are target consumers, and this is why there has been a proliferation of reasonably priced wines with cute or stylish labels. Yellow Tail (a brand of Casella Wines) became an instant success with it’s artful wallaby, Vincor (itself a subsidiary of Constellation Brands) came up with Kumala, and Peller Estates created an entire subsidiary in Roundpetal to produce XOXO, Croc Crossing and others… all  to market to women.

I’m all in favour of the above. I think it is in a business’s best interest to locate potential buyers and market to them. Businesses that fail to do so alienate huge swaths of the populace.

My beef, however, is with the flagrant implications that “Mommyjuice” and “Mommy’s Time Out” create.

While being a stay-at-home mom is certainly a difficult and sometimes stressful job, and I take no issue with a parent enjoying a glass of wine at the end of the day, I find the implication that alcohol is the answer to be in poor taste. It is entirely possible to market to this demographic without the suggestion that the need for alcohol is in direct relation to their children.

In wine tasting lingo, a dirty wine is one that is poorly made, that gives off a foul or pungent smell. I define dirty marketing as much the same.

Disclaimer: I own shares in one of the companies mentioned in this post. I post the link not as a recommendation, but rather so readers can see what the bottles look like.

3 responses to “Dirty Marketing

  1. Dammit…I just posted a reply and the internet ate it. In a nutshell, yes, I completely agree with you. A) the names are tacky, which would put me off as a consumer anyway B) they seem to buy into the cultural understanding of women as not that far removed from children anyway (‘juice’? a ‘time out’?) – who talks like this to another adult? I imagine mumsnet has a much more outraged reaction to the whole thing! Also, can you imagine the implications courted by a parallel product called ‘daddyjuice’ or similar?

    And yes – sorry! I did get your email – everything from the end of March to now has disappeared into a haze of marking, exam boards, and faculty meetings… I will email soon. I made Louis a present too – actually, i made two then ran out of yarn on one…Also, apparently young children are far smaller than my cat.

  2. Hi Kaley,
    Thanks for the comment.
    The names are, indeed, tacky. I agree. I could see something like this being marketed as a joke at The It Store or something, but to have it in wine shops is just insulting to all involved.

    I was thinking the same thing. I imagine a whiskey labeled “Daddy’s Mouthwash” would cause quite the stir.

    Wow. I’m touched that you would handcraft something for the little guy. Looking forward to it. I am quite concerned about your cat, though.

  3. Pingback: Weekend Reading: Bitcoin Heist Edition | Invest It Wisely

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s